
Chaplin - 15th Anniversary Edition
Robert Downey, Jr
4 out of 5 stars
Reviewed for Coffeerooms by Mike Jefferson
Charlie Chaplin is to comedy what The Beatles are to music. Chaplin was Hollywood's first million dollar superstar, and his slapstick comedies revolutionized silent film. Without Chaplin, there might not have been a Marx Brothers, certainly no Three Stooges and maybe no Robin Williams, Jim Carrey, or Dave Chappelle. Instead, we might be talking about Charlie Chase, Harold Lloyd, or Ben Turpin as the founding fathers of comedy. Who? Never heard of those guys? Lloyd actually made more money during his career than Chaplin, yet today, it's the "Little Tramp" that's remembered.
Fifteen years ago, Sir Richard Attenborough (who'd directed "Gandi" and would go on to star in "Jurassic Park"), took on the seemingly impossible task of telling Chaplin's life story. Any number of the highlights (or lowlights) in Chaplin's 88 years of existence could have been a film by itself - living in abject poverty with his step brother, Sydney, and his mentally ill mother; trolling London's impoverished streets; creating the character of "The Little Tramp," a comic, sentimental every man; getting married four times; his endless stream of underage lovers; been dogged out of the country by J. Edgar Hoover; or returning to the U.S. in his 80s to receive the longest standing ovation in history of the Oscars. Compressing Chaplin's faults and accomplishments into two plus hours was one hurdle -- finding someone the public would accept as The Little Tramp was even harder. When Robert Downey, Jr. an American actor, was chosen to play Chaplin, a collective "What the #$!!!" shook the entire movie community. The choice of Downey seemed absurd; not only was he battling a mind-numbing substance abuse problem, he'd never shown a knack for physical comedy, and that not being English thing would be a real slap in the face to Brits if he tripped over Chaplin's accent.
Not only did Downey master Chaplin's aristocratic accent, he xeroxed his brand of acrobatic comedy, reflected the hurt of his early years, and captured his lonely existence at the top. Downey didn't just study Chaplin, he absorbed him, from his duck-footed walk, to his visual tics, and horny as a goat hedonism. Downey's saturation of Chaplin comes to the fore when Chaplin resists the advent of talkies. It's easy to play a flamboyant, larger-than-life personality in his heyday, but Downey's portrayal of Chaplin becomes more multi-dimensional as his career begins to go into eclipse. When J. Edgar Hoover mounts a crusade to deport Chaplin, The Tramp becomes more fastidious, more of a perfectionist, determined to promote a message behind the laughter. While creating "The Great Dictator," Chaplin realizes talking in a film will be the end of The Tramp, "But at least he'll go out saying something I believe in."









