Girls night...8 gals

[Dragonmom]

Well...overall I thought the guys did better. But still some did a good job. Here's what I thought of each one:

Asia'h....Just okay to me

Kady..Boring! forgettable

Amanda..She has her unique style..and she has a great voice..but it's getting old to me

Carly...I didn't care for the song..but her voice is awesome

Kristy...Better song for her..put that Country influence on it. More her type of song..good

Ramielle...good voice, but the performance just did not wow me

Brooke...She's a folksy type singer. I like her!! Loved it

Syesha...Like her. High notes great

Who do I think will go home tomorrow? Kady for sure and perhaps Asia'h or Ramielle

[Agent99]

I have to agree with you on the performances. I thought Brooke's version of "Love/Battlefield" was amazing. I am not impressed with Ramielle either. She has the pipes but she is just so boring. There's no life to her when she sings. I think Kristy and Kady are going. Syesha is unbelievable. It's always risky to sing Whitney but she pulled it off! I gotta give it to Amanda tonight. She was great. Now let's see her sing a Barry Manilow song!

[dylanangel75]

The girls the girls the girls... here goes
Asia'h Epperson - I liked it. I am tired of the comparisons to the original artists because she wasn't trying to be Whitney.

Kady Malloy- Like it or not this girl can sing. Is it a little to late? Yea I think so

Amanda Overmyer- Liked it but she should have went last week and what was with her attitude after she was finished. Major put off with that. She shouldn't be there anyway so I want her to go. She was outperformed last week by 10 other girls!!

Carly Smithson- Being a HUGE Celine Dion fan I was worried but she did amazing.

Kristy Lee Cook- What a beautiful girl and to do Journey my all time fav band was worrisome but she did good. I liked the country spin.

Ramiele Malubay- Girl has pipes but she left them at the hotel. Didn't like it. She should go home for this performance. She was outperformed by 6 other girls.

Brooke White- I thought she did fantastic. I loved the arrangement.

BEST OF THE NIGHT BY FAR>>>>
Syesha Mercado- WOW work that Whitney song girl. She sounded amazing.

[Dragonmom]

agent 99...Amanda doing a Barry Manilow song would be something to see and hear!! If she can pull that off..she'll get my vote a bit longer. Because..they are going to ask them to sing songs out of their comfort range before too long.

[Agent99]

And that's what I'm waiting for! I'm not so sure she will be able to pull off any type of ballad.

[KrisMich]

If I had to pick, I'd send Kady and Asia'h home. Kady hasn't impressed me one bit this whole time and her attitude stinks. Asia'h has done okay, but her voice is somewhat common.

Although I've not been an Amanda fan, she did very well last night. But, what else can she do? I agree with Agent, I doubt she'll be able to pull off a ballad.

The girls all have pipes, but they are lacking personality on stage in my opinion. My favorite right now is Brooke. I loved her "Love Is a Battlefield".

[D00L1Fan]

My pick is Kristy and Kady to leave this week....As some of you know I really like Amanda but she has been a disappointment for me over the last 2 weeks..but last night I got what I was hoping for...a song that actually suited her and she did great....As someone mentioned, why she couldn't smile or show some gratitude for the compliments that come hard for her, I dont know..bad move to me..especially for those rooting for her.

Carly, to me, sings anything well...

Brooke to me was the best of the night...I LOVED that acoustic version of Pat's song...loved it loved it loved it..