May 18...3 perform tonight

[Dragonmom]

Well...this is a tough one. I'm not sure anymore who will win, and the one's I loved have already been voted off. Of the three left...tough knowing who's gonna win. This is what I thought about tonight's performances:
All three sang three songs...

1) Scotty..the first one was his choice.
Amazed by you. Very good
Second choice was Jimmy Ivy's choice (that's the guys' name right?) Are you Gonna Kiss me? Scotty played the guitar..loved this one even more than his first song. He did well...Love the twinkle in his pretty blue eyes.
Third Choice...A Kenny Rogers song..She Believes in Me. It was alright..didn't wow me, but overall Scotty is consistant every week. And he's a really sweet guy

2) Lauren... First song..her choice: Faith Hill song..Wild One. Just so so for me. To me the tempo was too fast or something?
Second choice..was Jimmy's choice: If I die Young. I loved it! I had tears in my eyes. She did well
Third Choice: Judges choice: I Hope you Dance: Loved her dress... she did ok

3) Haley...First song she chose was: Can't remember the title..oops. Loved her dress...very sexy. Her father played guitar. Judges loved her! She did good...just never heard of that song. But her stage performance was great. Poor thing fell going up some steps..but she got right up and kept on going.

Second song..Jimmy's choice: A Stevie Nicks song. Loved the fan blowing her dress and hair... but Stevie did it better. Loved her dress again

Third song... Judges choice: Forgot the name of the song again...but she did well.

First round... My choice was a tie between Scotty and Haley

Second round... my choice..again a tie ..between Scotty and Lauren

Third round...my choice..Haley

Oh gee... who will go home? I really don't know..it's tough! I think at this point..I'm gonna root for Scotty to win this whole thing.

[KrisMich]

You are right, DM...a very tough one to call. I'm rooting for Scotty, just because he's been so consistent through the whole thing. He knows who he is musically and he has great stage presence. The girls probably need to win more than Scotty as I believe Scotty will be signed quickly if he doesn't win. All are good in so many ways and like you, DM, my first picks have already been sent packin', so it's so hard to call. I wish them all well.

[Passionatic]

I'm a Haley fan, so I thought she did fantastic on her first 2 numbers! I loved seeing her Dad play guitar for her, that was so cool! I did not like her last song at all, I thought she was struggling all thru it. Scotty is just so cute and got such an enjoyable style to his singing(and I'm not even a country music fan), I think he could win it all...he's going to get votes from teen girls and from their Moms :)
I'm not a fan of Lauren, she's cute, but has breath control problems, she always sounds like she's going to run out of breath at the end of her songs, and I HATE the way the stylists dress her...waaay too old looking, dress her like a 16 year old! So I'm hoping its a Scotty&Haley finale, I'd be happy with either one winning.

[Dragonmom]

I loved seeing Haley's dad play guitar for her too.