The Top 11 Perform..March 23

[Dragonmom]

Well...Some of the song choices tonight..just didn't wow me. But here's my take on all of the singers:

1) Lee...I still love him. I loved the brass playing and he looked more comfortable on stage. Judges loved him except for Simon. He has a good voice..just think I would have chosen another song..instead of "The Letter". I don't want him to go

2) Paige..I'm sorry but she did awful. Her voice to me sounded like she was quivering. Judges were all negative. I think she might be the one to go this week

3) Tim..I can't believe Ellen said the same thing I was thinking..his performance was corny. Oh..the girls will love him..and he'll probably be saved once again. His voice isn't bad..just forgettable to me. It did sound like a High school musical version..like one judge said.

4) Aaron...Such a cute kid! He did well...nice voice.

5) Crystal...Love love love...the Bobby McGee song..and of course I've always thought of her as a Janis Joplin type singer. Loved it..loved it!

6) Big Mike...He did alright

7) Andrew..Just so so. I like the guy..but he's going backwards instead of forward. I'm afraid for him. But hope he hangs around another week.

8) Katie...She has a nice voice and it was better than last week, to me, but she's just forgettable

9) Casey..Sang the Power of Love..like I said..I am not so sure about some of the song choices tonight. But he did a good job with it.

10) DiDi..Another forgettable singer. It was just ok

11) Siobhan...all loved her but Simon. I'm always looking forward to see what she's wearing and how her hair will be. Those high notes of hers...wow! You either like her or you don't. I like her!

My overall fav was Crystal this week. It just comes so easy for her! I think of all the singers...Paige had the most trouble..just wasn't good. She might be going home.

[Agent99]

I wish three could go home - Paige, Tim and Andrew. I agree with Simon when he said about Andrew that maybe everyone just over-reacted to him and he only had one good song.

[Dragonmom]

I say Paige should go home. Eventually I think Tim and Didi. Didi's voice is ok..just rather boring. Poor Andrew..I liked him at the beginning..but he's had some bad weeks.

[KrisMich]

Paige is also my choice to go. I watched it after my rehearsal last night and she was simply awful. Poor kid, but I do believe this is her week to go.

I like Andrew, but agree that maybe he's the "one hit wonder" of the season and peaked too soon in Hollywood. He's not done very well since.

I'm still a fan of Big Mike and my favorite this season (so far) is still Crystal. Bobby McGee was the perfect song for her.

[pjp]

Devastating night for several contestants.
Paige...was really bad.
Tim... corny I made the comment when he was performing that it looked stiff and forced so when the judges mentioned corny it fit.
Andrew...I really liked him during Hollywood week but he has steadily gone down hill since.
DiDi... I like her singing voice but last nights song choice and performance was forgetable. I knew what Simon was going to say before he said it. The song title said it all.
Katie... is not one of my favorites and she should have been gone instead of Lacy. JMO
I pretty much liked the rest of the singers with Crystal by far the best
Mike is starting to get a bit boring to me. He sings great but needs to change things up a bit???
Siobhan is fun to watch but the one note is getting predictable and old??? JMO
Casey is going to hang in a while yet, I bet :O)
Aaron is cute and is doing really good
Lee isn't one of my favorites right now but that could change. nothing to do with his singing because he is good but for some reason he just doesn't wow me.

Bottom three tonight
Paige
Tim
Andrew or maybe Katie or maybe DiDi
dang like I said a devastating night.